US Regulators Urge Scrutiny as AI Sector Grows

Unlock the Editor’s Digest for free. Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favourite stories in this weekly newsletter.

The Rise of AI: A Concern for Antitrust Regulators

The top US antitrust enforcer has expressed an urgent need to scrutinize the artificial intelligence (AI) sector. This comes in light of rising concerns that power over this transformative technology is consolidating among a select group of wealthy companies.

Investigating Choke Points in AI Competition

In an interview with the Financial Times, Jonathan Kanter, the head of antitrust enforcement at the Department of Justice (DoJ), emphasized the need to examine “monopoly choke points and the competitive landscape” within the AI sector. This includes everything from computational resources and training data for large language models to cloud service providers and access to vital hardware such as graphics processing unit (GPU) chips.

Concerns Over Market Dominance

Kanter voiced concerns that the emerging AI sector is currently at a peak for competition rather than the starting point, urging regulators to act with speed to prevent established tech giants from monopolizing the market.

Real-Time Intervention: A Delicate Approach

“Sometimes the most significant intervention is when actions are taken in real-time,” Kanter stated. “This approach allows regulators to be less invasive, potentially achieving their objectives without stifling innovation.”

A Tougher Antitrust Stance

Now in his third year with the DoJ, Kanter has collaborated closely with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to adopt a more rigorous antitrust policy. This includes legal actions against major tech players like Google and Apple, which the government accuses of maintaining unfair monopoly advantages in their services.

Focus on Generative AI and Microchips

At present, regulatory bodies are turning their attention to the generative AI sector and assessing the competitive dynamics in the microchip market.

GPUs: Scarcity and Market Power

Kanter pointed out that the GPUs necessary for training large language models have become increasingly scarce resources. Nvidia, which leads in advanced GPU sales, saw its market capitalization surpass that of Apple this week, making it the world’s second-most valuable publicly traded company.

Dividing Oversight Between Agencies

According to sources, the DoJ and FTC have reached an agreement to delineate antitrust oversight among key AI players. The DoJ will focus on investigating Nvidia, while the FTC will evaluate the actions of Microsoft and OpenAI.

Balancing Public Interest and Corporate Strategy

Kanter referenced government initiatives aimed at bolstering domestic production, such as the $39 billion proposed in the Chips Act. However, he noted that antitrust regulators are also monitoring how chipmakers allocate their most advanced products amid soaring demand.

Conflict of Interest in Resource Allocation

“It’s essential to consider potential conflicts of interest,” Kanter remarked. “When companies prioritize competitive implications over profitability, regulatory concerns may arise.”

The Arms Race in AI Development

Since the sensational launch of OpenAI’s ChatGPT in November 2022, a fierce competition has emerged, with companies vying for lucrative partnerships with leading AI firms and developers.

High-Stakes Investments

Notably, Microsoft’s $13 billion investment in OpenAI secured rights to its intellectual property and profits, although it did not result in ownership. This partnership, along with Google and Amazon’s multi-billion-dollar deals with rival Anthropic, is now under investigation by the FTC and EU competition agencies.

Circumventing Antitrust Laws?

In March, Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella announced the hiring of Mustafa Suleyman, a founder of another AI start-up, Inflection, along with most of its staff, to establish a new consumer AI division. This move raised suspicions among industry experts who saw it as an attempt to evade antitrust scrutiny.

Ongoing Investigations

The FTC is currently looking into whether Microsoft adequately reported its deal with Inflection. A Microsoft representative insisted that the company complies with all legal transaction reporting obligations.

Focusing on the Bigger Picture

Kanter confirmed that the FTC is scrutinizing “acqui-hires” more seriously and emphasized that regulators are focusing on market realities rather than the formal presentation of these transactions.

Microsoft’s Defense

In response to allegations of unfair influence, Microsoft maintains that its partnerships have indeed fostered competition. The company asserts that without its involvement, start-ups like OpenAI may not have reached their current potential.

Conclusion: The Path Forward

As the landscape of AI continues to evolve, the balance between regulation and innovation remains a critical challenge. Regulators face the task of ensuring fair competition while allowing for technological advancement in this booming industry.

Questions and Answers

• What concerns are regulators expressing about the AI sector?
  Regulators are worried about the concentration of power among a few major players and the potential for monopolistic behavior.
• What is Jonathan Kanter’s role in this context?
  Kanter leads antitrust enforcement at the DoJ and focuses on ensuring competitive practices are maintained in the AI sector.
• What specific markets are currently under scrutiny?
  Regulators are examining the generative AI sector and the competitive dynamics surrounding GPU production.
• How have major companies responded to allegations of antitrust violations?
  Companies like Microsoft argue that their partnerships actually enhance competition in the marketplace.
• What is the significance of the Chips Act mentioned by Kanter?
  The Chips Act aims to support domestic chip production to alleviate supply constraints and boost competition in the market.