DeepSeek’s AI Chatbot vs. ChatGPT: Unraveling Sensitive Questions About China

0
10
DeepSeek's new AI chatbot and ChatGPT answer sensitive questions about China differently

DeepSeek’s AI Chatbot vs. ChatGPT: A Glimpse into AI Development and Geopolitics

The Rise of a New Contender

Chinese tech startup DeepSeek has recently launched an artificial intelligence chatbot that is garnering attention and discussion regarding the competitive landscape between China and the U.S. in AI development. Users are flocking to test this new rival to OpenAI’s ChatGPT.

Soaring Popularity

DeepSeek’s AI assistant quickly ascended to the No. 1 spot as the most downloaded free app on Apple’s iPhone store shortly after its release. The chatbot’s launch has reportedly caused a dip in stocks for prominent tech companies on Wall Street, igniting interest in whether DeepSeek can compete with leading U.S. AI firms at a significantly lower cost.

Understanding the Impact

The long-term impact of DeepSeek’s chatbot on the AI industry remains uncertain. Observers have noted that it appears to censor responses regarding sensitive topics related to China—a practice commonly found on the Chinese internet. In 2023, China introduced regulations mandating that companies undergo security reviews and obtain necessary approvals prior to launching their products.

A Comparison with ChatGPT

The Associated Press tested DeepSeek’s chatbot against ChatGPT to assess their responses to various sensitive questions. One question posed was, “What does Winnie the Pooh mean in China?”

Winnie the Pooh and Political Satire

For many in China, Winnie the Pooh is seen as a playful mockery of President Xi Jinping. In the past, the character has faced censorship, with social media searches banned in mainland China. While ChatGPT recognized this symbolism of political satire, DeepSeek’s chatbot framed the bear as a beloved character enjoyed by children and families, concluding with a statement about the government’s commitment to a wholesome cyberspace.

Current U.S. Leadership

When asked about the current U.S. president, both AI chatbots mistakenly identified Joe Biden, stating their data was last updated in October 2023. They both advised users to consult verified sources for up-to-date information.

Tiananmen Square: A Taboo Subject

In response to questions about the Tiananmen Square crackdown in June 1989, DeepSeek’s chatbot refrained from providing details, saying, “Sorry, that’s beyond my current scope. Let’s talk about something else.” Conversely, ChatGPT offered an in-depth analysis of the events, detailing the protests, resulting casualties, and their enduring legacy.

The State of U.S.-China Relations

When discussing U.S.-China relations, DeepSeek’s chatbot echoed official Chinese rhetoric, describing the relationship as essential and expressing hopes for mutual respect and cooperation. Phrases like “meet … halfway” and “win-win cooperation” reflected language often used by Chinese officials.

A Nuanced Perspective

ChatGPT, however, presented a more nuanced view, emphasizing the complexity of U.S.-China relations characterized by economic ties, geopolitical rivalry, and collaboration on global issues. It highlighted ongoing tensions surrounding the South China Sea and Taiwan as central topics in their interactions.

The Taiwan Question

When asked if Taiwan is part of China, DeepSeek’s chatbot reiterated the Chinese government’s claim of Taiwan’s status as an integral part of China. ChatGPT, on the other hand, noted that perspectives on this issue vary. It explained the differing views of both China and Taiwan, alongside international community stances.

The Future of AI in Geopolitics

As technological advancements continue to unfold, it will be essential to monitor how AI systems like DeepSeek’s chatbot evolve and influence public discourse, especially regarding sensitive geopolitical issues.

Conclusion: The Duality of AI Responses

The contrasting responses from DeepSeek’s and ChatGPT’s chatbots reveal not only differences in their programming and objectives but also highlight the broader implications of AI development in a global context. As artificial intelligence gains traction around the world, the way sensitive topics are handled will be critical in shaping public perception and narrative.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

  1. What is DeepSeek’s chatbot?
    DeepSeek’s chatbot is an AI assistant developed by a Chinese startup, aimed at competing with existing AI chatbots like ChatGPT.
  2. Why was Winnie the Pooh banned in China?
    Winnie the Pooh has been seen as a satirical representation of President Xi Jinping, leading to censorship of the character on Chinese social media.
  3. What happened during the Tiananmen Square crackdown?
    The crackdown in June 1989 involved government troops firing on pro-democracy protesters, resulting in numerous casualties. The event remains a sensitive topic in China.
  4. What do the chatbots say about U.S.-China relations?
    DeepSeek’s chatbot reflected official Chinese perspectives, while ChatGPT offered a more nuanced view of the complexities in the relationship between the two countries.
  5. How do the chatbots differ in their responses?
    DeepSeek’s responses align closely with government narratives, while ChatGPT provides more comprehensive and balanced information on sensitive subjects.

source